Apple Pie Filling Recipe (2024)

Very delicious, but there was far too much liquid in the filling to use in a full pie. After chilling, I strained the juices back into the pot and reduced them to about 1/3 cup (as Erin recommends for similar fruit pies). Then added the reduced syrupy stuff back to the apples. No soggy bottom!

For me this recipe yielded an unpleasantly gluey and over-spiced pie. Too much of everything -- sugar, cinnamon, ginger -- overwhelmed the flavor of the apple. I suggest cutting way back on all the ingredients, except the apples!

This is an excellent template for making apple pie filling. I go all the way down to ~150 grams brown sugar + 60 grams granulated white sugar if I've got sweeter apples (Gala, Fuji, Honeycrisp, etc). I only use the full amounts if I've got a lot of Granny Smiths. If you're not sure, weigh out the brown sugar and add about half to the pot, pulling it off the heat and tasting as you go to see if it's sweet enough. Apples vary widely in sweetness, so it's worth taking your time with this step.

Perhaps after slicing and coring the apples, let them drain in a colander for about an hour and a half. Put a bowl under the colander to catch the juice and make a reduction from the juice to glaze the crust. Should take care of the problem of too much liquid.

used only one teaspoon of raw sugar, no brown. instead of corn starch, used pre-prepared chia seeds with blueberries. Used vegan butter instead of dairy butter. Added extra lemon juice. Chia takes up extra liquid. These helped raise the healthy level and helped rely on apples for sweet & tartness.

The first time I made this exactly as written, too sweet and too thick. Second time around, halved the sugar and only added 1 tablespoon of the white sugar/flour mixture. It was much better, suggest you edit according to your taste.

Tasty. Have not put in a pie, etc yet. Followed recipe exactly except skipped all granulated sugar and vanilla. Lemon adds nice flavor. Could get very thin if your apples have a lot of water content.

I halved this recipe and reduced both the brown and white sugars because my apples (a mix of Honeycrisp and Fuji) were pretty sweet on their own. AMAZING FILLING for hand pies! Since it's pre-cooked it's so perfect for tiny pies that aren't in the oven that long. It thickened up nicely, and I let the apples get a little extra soft (personal preference). Maybe not my favorite for a full pie though - the crust to filling ratio for this was perfect with hand pies.

I like the idea very much and I followed the recipe and video closely. It was quite gooey and heavy on the cinnamon and sugar. Having some of it tonight with ice cream and a crumble top.

Great stuff. I made it exactly as written (well, to be fair, I added some allspice in addition to the listed spices) and while it was definitely on the sweeter side, it was a big hit! I imagine the apple’s sweetness makes a big difference - mine were not super sweet to begin with. I’m not usually into fruit pies but this has opened my mind a bit. Absolutely lovely room temperature the day after baking. Held up great in a pie crust.

I found it too sweet and next time I’ll cut way down on the cinnamon,

Excellent. Made exactly as written.

This freezes well. I made several batches last year. It's good in a crust, or with a crumble topping without a crust.

Use less brown sugar and less cinnamon More lemon juiceLess regular sugar

I added ground cloves and a little turmeric for extra spice.

I didn’t have a lot of liquid as others did as I just softed the apples rather than cooking them down so the pie has some bite: I actually needed to add a little more citrus juice to slacken off the sauce. Halved all the sugars and used only about a tablespoon of flour and only 2 teaspoons of cinnamon. Perfect.

Way too much spice and flour...I want an apple pie. Not a spicey gloppy mess.

This turned out really well, and goes great with a crumble topping. I highly recommend straining it out extra liquid and cooking it down to a caramel-y consistency.

I didn't have a lemon on hand (dang it!) so I used white wine vinegar, which worked out well. I also added in a tsp. of all spice and it ended up very yummy. After the apples baked down, I was also shocked how much liquid came out! I decided to follow Kristin's advice and reduced the liquid until it became thick and reminded me of an apple-y caramel. I couldn't stop munching on the cooked apples, they tasted great!

This is an excellent template for making apple pie filling. I go all the way down to ~150 grams brown sugar + 60 grams granulated white sugar if I've got sweeter apples (Gala, Fuji, Honeycrisp, etc). I only use the full amounts if I've got a lot of Granny Smiths. If you're not sure, weigh out the brown sugar and add about half to the pot, pulling it off the heat and tasting as you go to see if it's sweet enough. Apples vary widely in sweetness, so it's worth taking your time with this step.

Perhaps after slicing and coring the apples, let them drain in a colander for about an hour and a half. Put a bowl under the colander to catch the juice and make a reduction from the juice to glaze the crust. Should take care of the problem of too much liquid.

Tasty. Have not put in a pie, etc yet. Followed recipe exactly except skipped all granulated sugar and vanilla. Lemon adds nice flavor. Could get very thin if your apples have a lot of water content.

used only one teaspoon of raw sugar, no brown. instead of corn starch, used pre-prepared chia seeds with blueberries. Used vegan butter instead of dairy butter. Added extra lemon juice. Chia takes up extra liquid. These helped raise the healthy level and helped rely on apples for sweet & tartness.

The first time I made this exactly as written, too sweet and too thick. Second time around, halved the sugar and only added 1 tablespoon of the white sugar/flour mixture. It was much better, suggest you edit according to your taste.